Jan C. Still Lugerforums banner

Black Widow Grips

16332 Views 48 Replies 16 Participants Last post by  tracy
I was cleaning my byf 41 (48XX v) and upon removing the grips, remembered there were some interesting threads on the subject that were "sticky-d" by Jan including some about fakes, and the identifying marks of the "real" ones. It seemed most guys thought that if you had the pistol in your posession for long enough or it was up in Canada away from the fakers, it would most likely be the real deal.

I took some pics of them which I can't resize small enough to post myself, so if I could send them to someone to post I would appreciate it.

They have ONE of the holes mentioned on the inside, the lower one, and there are casting flashings where the upper hole might have been located in the mold at some point, but both have only ONE hole in them.

I bought this pistol and several others from a collector in 1976 as a Black Widow (he described it on the Bill of Sale in this manner). No one has ever fooled with this as long as I have had it, and I believe the gentleman who owned it had it in his possession for a number of years.

Since I can account for it for over 29 years myself and would imagine him having it for five or more (he got out of pistols and went into stamps. These grips show some wear and a few scratches, so no collector would bother to scratch them up to try to fool anyone 30 years ago, maybe now, but not then I don't think. I wonder if anyone who knows can tell us WHEN the fake grips started to be produced?

Now I read where the real ones have TWO holes in the back and they are threaded so they could use a grip screw to remove them from the mold. Please....what guy in a factory would take the time to thread in a fine threaded grip screw to remove it from the mold? Perhaps if a tool was used to pop them out, it could simply be put in the hole and torqued to the side to remove it from the mold, or if the idea that someone took the time to thread in a tool to remove them, why would they use a SMALL thread size that could break, chip or cross-thread so easily for ONE task only; removing it from the mold? On the other hand, is it a coincidence that the thread size of the tool to remove the grip from the mold (if that is what it is) happens to be the same size as the grip screw is?

Just playing devil's advocate here since some think TWO holes on the back are necessary for it to be "real", and they have to be threaded the same size as the grip screw is. Heck, the holes in mine appear to have been threaded, but have threads in them or have had the threads boogered up at some point and they are a bit smaller than 3/8"....hmm..just about 9mm!

Your thoughts, gentlemen?
See less See more
1 - 7 of 49 Posts
Chuck
Below are some previous discussions of "black widow" grips. They contain excellent information. My observations and those reported by fellow collectors (over 30 years) have not included "black widow" grips such as you show (large holes) in your post above as being original.
Jan

*Black Widows, (byf 41,photoes and grip details) Jim Goodman
------------------------- http://www.gunboards.com/luger/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=1095

*"Black Widow" grips bruv
------------------------- http://www.gunboards.com/luger/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=874

*Black Widows (detailed discussion) Ji
------------------------- http://www.gunboards.com/luger/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=770

*BLACK AND BROWN PLASTIC LUGER GRIPS Jan C Still
------------------------ http://www.gunboards.com/luger/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=1497
See less See more
Chuck
Apparently (judging from the length and number of your posts) establishing the credibility of your “black widow” grips is important to you. Based on your photographs of these grips, it has been determined that they are different from what most experienced collectors consider correct (no one has stated that your grips are fake). The “it came from a vet or has been in a safe” stories are a dime a dozen and have been used by dealers to sell junk to collectors for many years. Apparently the posts by me and fellow collectors are not exactly what you want to see. I would suggest that you do some in depth study of “black widow” grips your self. When your studies are complete please report them on this forum.
Thanks
Jan
Chuck
You are a little too sensitive/paranoid, no one has suggested that you are “rocking the boat” or “throwing rocks”. Please stick to the subject of pistol collecting.
Jan
Dave
According to Gibson "The Krieghoff Parabellum" page 42-47, the Mauser grips are black Bakelite. He also states that the term black bakelite "is technically incorrect" as the material is much softer than bakelite.

Someplace on this Forum, a post covered the chemical properities of the material in black Mauser grips. I did a quick search and couldnt find it. It may have been on the hacked Forum.
Jan
Chuck
Its clear that you do not accept the information that fellow collectors have shared with you in an attempt to be helpful. Looks like you have a great project, your items "1-7" above. Be sure to post when you finish your research.
Jan
Chuck
Looking at your photographs, I cannot say when I have seen a pair of original "black widow" grips fit so poorly. As Pete said "Chuck...I noticed the grips along the back grip strap do not seem to fit well...they do not go to the edge of the back strap..."

Sorry to say, I have real doubts that this luger left the factory with those poorly fitting grips(that leave the innards of the main spring exposed). Based on your photographs, my opinion is that the “black widow” grips on your Luger are most likely poor quality replacements or reproductions.
Jan
Chuck
Thanks for your photographs. I was surprised when I first saw the photographs of the grips on your Luger. The fit is terrible and I was surprised when you did not mention this important fact in 6 posts and many hundreds of words.

Numerous experts have spent their time and effort to give you their best advice. As you can see, this group takes collecting seriously. In my opinion, you are not listening seriously to them, because you enjoy the debate and the attention. There is an old saying “You can take a horse to water but you cannot make it drink (or understand).” The collectors on this Forum will wait patiently for you to complete and report on your detailed grip research (your items “1-7" above).
Jan
Note: in my opinion Chuck did not a waste our time. His questions forced us to better understand, review and summarize our “black widow” grip information. Excellent information has been presented. Thanks to all the collectors that participated.
1 - 7 of 49 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top