Jan C. Still Lugerforums banner
Cancel

TWO BEHOLLA’S AND A MENTA

Jump to Latest Follow
1 - 20 of 21 Posts
Jan C Still

· Premium Member
Joined
·
4,387 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
TWO BEHOLLA’S AND A MENTA, SUPPLEMENTARY ARMY PISTOLS

Manufacture of the Beholla started in 1915 at Becker and Hollander in Suhl, Germany. 22 are reported in the 5 to 43853 serial range and almost all bear a German military acceptance stamp. Some in the later serial range bear a trigger guard eagle ( termed Prussian Eagle). About 45,000 were manufactured for the wartime German Army.

BEHOLLA SERIAL NUMBERS AND DESCRIPTIONS (Military stamped unless noted otherwise)
5 (no military stamp)
360
774
2096, (groved wood grips)
4074
5492
5494
7689, (plastic grips)
14849
15401
16064
16461(trigger guard eagle)
19597
22718 (trigger guard eagle)
23756 (trigger guard eagle)(groved wood grips)
25545 (trigger guard eagle)
27293 (trigger guard eagle)
27397
27858 (trigger guard eagle)
29507 (groved wood grips)(trigger guard eagle)
30003
30019 (trigger guard eagle)(groved wood grips)
36767(trigger guard eagle)
37310 (trigger guard eagle)
40094 (trigger guard eagle)(checkered wood grips)
43853(no military stamp)

The Menta is basically the same pistol as the Beholla except that it was manufactured by August Menz in Suhl, Germany. Only 4 are reported in the 1432 to 10638 serial range. Only three of these, sn 9566 (plastic grips), 10567(plastic grips) and 10638, bear the German military acceptance stamp. (This same pistol was also manufactured as the Leonhardt and Stenda)

Both the Beholla and Menta are listed in the August 8, 1917 dated list of pistols offered for sale by the Prussian Army Arsenal to officers. (Still Volume I, page 127) The Beholla is listed at 41 marks and the Menta at 35 marks.


Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa1.jpg
55.65 KB
Figure 1. Top to bottom: Beholla, serial number 7689; Beholla, serial number 40094; and Menta, serial number 10567. All three bear the C/D German Army acceptance stamp. In addition, the Beholla in the middle bears a Prussian Eagle on the front trigger guard.



Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa2.jpg
33.16 KB
Figure 2. Beholla, serial number 7689. Left side. It bears an Imperial Army C/D on the left frame; and a commercial C/N on the left frame, left slide and left barrel.


Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa3.jpg
33.6 KB
Figure 3. Beholla, serial number 7689. Right side, showing the manufacturer name, Becker & Hollander.


Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa4.jpg
42.77 KB
Figure 4. Beholla, serial number 7689. Left side, markings details.


Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa5.jpg
53.69 KB
Figure 5. Beholla, serial number 7689. Showing inside of matching horn grips.


Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa6.jpg
53.86 KB
Figure 6. Beholla, serial number 7689, with Imperial military holster and extra magazine.


Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa7.jpg
46.39 KB
Figure 7. Beholla, serial number 7689, with open Imperial military holster.


Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa8.jpg
47.42 KB
Figure 8. Holster manufacturing hallmark, 1917 date, and Imperial B.A. XII (12 th Army Corps) 18, stamp.
 
Jan C Still

· Premium Member
Joined
·
4,387 Posts
Discussion Starter · #2 ·
Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa9.jpg
31.91KB
Figure 9. Beholla, serial number 40094. Left side. It bears an Imperial Army C/D on the left frame; and a commercial C/N on the left frame, left slide and left barrel.



Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa10.jpg
35.65KB
Figure 10. Beholla, serial number 40094. Right side, showing the manufacturer name, Becker & Hollander.


Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa11.jpg
38.34KB
Figure 11. Beholla, serial number 40094. Left side, markings details.


Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa12.jpg
73.11KB
Figure 12. Beholla, serial number 40094. Showing inside of matching wood grips.


Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa13.jpg
29.97KB
Figure 13. Beholla, serial number 40094. Showing Imperial Eagle stamped on the front trigger guard. According to a directive dated July 1918, supplementary pistols were to bear an Imperial Eagle (of the largest possible size) as a measure to prevent theft.


Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa14.jpg
33.07KB
Figure 14. Menta, serial number 10567. Left side. It bears an Imperial Army C/D on the left frame; and a commercial C/N on the left frame, left slide and left barrel.



Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa15.jpg
31.63KB
Figure 15. Menta, serial number 10567. Right side. It’s grips are of plastic and unmarked.


Download Attachment: MENTABEHOLLAa16.jpg
26.35KB
Figure 16. Menta, serial number 10567. Left side, markings details.


Download Attachment: R.I.R.7217.jpg
176.25KB
Figure 17. Soldiers of the Reserve Infantry Regiment 72 during World War I. The second from right is armed with a 7,65 caliber (supplementary) pistol. The holsters for these pistols often had an inexact fit (one size fits all).
 
K

· Registered
Joined
·
216 Posts
#8 ·
Interesting holster. The BS is found with or without dots and guns of Reichswehr era. I have one Luger clip which is B.S. plus number marked on the spine. It would be interesting to know whether there is a difference between B.S. and BS in meaning. Regards Dietrich
 
R

· Registered
Joined
·
249 Posts
#9 ·
Dietrich,
The BS marks seem to vary from the normal police stamps.
I also have two long guns which are marked in this way.
The Gewehr 98 is B. S. stamped on the receiver ring,while
the Kar 98AZ is BS identified at the same location. Both
are 1920 'double-dated', but neither has a weapon number
appearing in conjunction with the BS property markings.

Rich M.
 
K

· Registered
Joined
·
216 Posts
#10 ·
You are correct. My Gew.98 is a Spandau 1915 Reichswehr conversion for s.S. cartridge and has the B.S. mark on receiver as well as on the stamping disc. Both without an inventory number. Thanks for your input. Regards Dietrich
 
K

· Registered
Joined
·
216 Posts
#11 ·
Dear Jan and fellow collectors. Here another serial number of my Beholla. It bears the Imperial eagle on the triggerguard and has the long serrated wooden grip panels which are numbered on the inside to the gun. Serial number is 23 756. Regards Dietrich
 
J

· Registered
Joined
·
257 Posts
#13 ·
The different stocks raise a question.
In his book Pistols of World War I, Robert Adamek shows Beholla #2096 (I think it's a zero) with grooved wood stocks. He states that early examples had grooved hardwood stocks, and later ones had plastic.
Seeing the posts here, I'm beginning to question that statement.
JT
 
R

· Registered
Joined
·
249 Posts
#15 ·
I'm pretty sure most of the early ones did indeed have plastic grips.
The wooden ones stayed until the name changeover to 'Stenda' happened.
At least that's the way it's supposed to have gone. Here's some Stenda
pistol photos I found while googling a while back. There is a lot of
variation it would seem, so judge for yourself. The first is an
interesting hybrid of features and markings.

Download Attachment: WW1StendaL.jpg
35.64KB

Download Attachment: WW1StendaR.jpg
36.61KB

Download Attachment: Stenda1.jpg
18.24KB

Download Attachment: Stenda-filled.jpg
39.28KB
 
Olefogey

· Silver Bullet Member
Joined
·
1,704 Posts
#18 ·
Jan, I hope this isn't too late to add to the list, but I just picked up a Beholla today (a bit of a roach!!), with imperial eagle on the trigger guard, C/D and C/N on the left side and grooved wooden grips. Serial #18246.

Dave
 
1 - 20 of 21 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
About this Discussion
20 Replies
9 Participants
Last post:
modar
Jan C. Still Lugerforums
A community dedicated to Lugers, Central Powers, Axis, Allied and related WW-I and WW-II pistols by their scholars, collectors, owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about the history, technology and extraordinary background associated with these design masterpieces.
Full Forum Listing
Explore Our Forums
New Collectors Board German: German Mfg. (non-P08) Pistols & Holsters. 1933-1945: Mauser Lugers. Army, Navy, Police German: Foreign Mfg. Pistols and Holsters. 1900-1918: P.08-Army Lugers
Top